[{"_1":2,"_3":-5,"_4":-5},"loaderData",{"_5":6,"_7":8,"_9":10},"actionData","errors","root",{"_251":252},"routes/_layout",{"_11":171},"routes/entity.$type.$id",{"_11":12,"_13":14,"_15":16,"_17":18,"_19":20,"_21":22,"_23":24,"_25":26,"_27":28},"dehydratedState",{"_71":72,"_73":74},"type","paper","id","paper_W2119170250","section","authors","entity",{"_15":16,"_29":30,"_31":-5,"_32":-5,"_33":-5,"_34":-5,"_35":36,"_37":38,"_39":-5,"_40":41,"_42":43,"_44":45,"_46":47,"_48":-5,"_49":50,"_51":30,"_52":53,"_54":55,"_56":57,"_58":-5,"_59":60,"_18":-5,"_61":62,"_63":-5,"_64":65,"_66":30,"_67":-5},"canonical","https://www.hugmap.com/entity/paper/paper_W2119170250/authors","siteBaseUrl","https://www.hugmap.com","sectionCount",3,"jsonLd","{\"@context\":\"https://schema.org\",\"@graph\":[{\"name\":\"An analysis and critique ofResearch through Design\",\"url\":\"https://www.hugmap.com/entity/paper/paper_W2119170250/authors\",\"@type\":\"ScholarlyArticle\",\"headline\":\"An analysis and critique ofResearch through Design\",\"datePublished\":\"2010-08-16\"},{\"@type\":\"CollectionPage\",\"name\":\"An analysis and critique ofResearch through Design 作者\",\"description\":\"An analysis and critique ofResearch through Design 在 HugMap 中的作者，共 3 条，含结构化关联信息与详情链接。\",\"url\":\"https://www.hugmap.com/entity/paper/paper_W2119170250/authors\",\"inLanguage\":\"zh-CN\"},{\"@type\":\"BreadcrumbList\",\"itemListElement\":[{\"@type\":\"ListItem\",\"position\":1,\"name\":\"首页\",\"item\":\"https://www.hugmap.com/\"},{\"@type\":\"ListItem\",\"position\":2,\"name\":\"论文\",\"item\":\"https://www.hugmap.com/search?type=paper\"},{\"@type\":\"ListItem\",\"position\":3,\"name\":\"An analysis and critique ofResearch through Design\",\"item\":\"https://www.hugmap.com/entity/paper/paper_W2119170250\"},{\"@type\":\"ListItem\",\"position\":4,\"name\":\"作者\",\"item\":\"https://www.hugmap.com/entity/paper/paper_W2119170250/authors\"}]}]}","name","An analysis and critique ofResearch through Design","nameZh","aliases","description","descriptionZh","status","active","externalIds","{\"openalex\":\"W2119170250\",\"doi\":\"10.1145/1858171.1858228\"}","properties","source","openalex","createdAt","2026-05-16T08:29:48.440914289","updatedAt","2026-05-19T04:17:28.19312447","doi","10.1145/1858171.1858228","arxivId","openalexId","W2119170250","title","abstractText","The field of HCI is experiencing a growing interest in Research through Design (RtD), a research approach that employs methods and processes from design practice as a legitimate method of inquiry. We are interested in expanding and formalizing this research approach, and understanding how knowledge, or theory, is generated from this type of design research. We conducted interviews with 12 leading HCI design researchers, asking them about design research, design theory, and RtD specifically. They were easily able to identify different types of design research and design theory from contemporary and historical design research efforts, and believed that RtD might be one of the most important contributions of design researchers to the larger research community. We further examined three historical RtD projects that were repeatedly mentioned in the interviews, and performed a critique of current RtD practices within the HCI research and interaction design communities. While our critique summarizes the problems, it also shows possible directions for further developments and refinements of the approach.","publishedDate","2010-08-16","publishedYear",2010,"venue","citationCount",473,"keywords",[68,69,70],"pdfUrl","topVenue",false,"displayName","displayDescription","Innovative Human-Technology Interaction","Persona Design and Applications","Usability and User Interface Design","mutations",[],"queries",[75],{"_76":77,"_78":79,"_80":81,"_82":83},"dehydratedAt",1784562378109,"state",{"_85":86,"_87":88,"_89":77,"_90":-5,"_91":92,"_93":92,"_94":92,"_95":-5,"_96":-5,"_97":65,"_35":98,"_99":100},"queryKey",[84,19,14,16],"queryHash","[\"portal\",\"entity\",\"paper\",\"paper_W2119170250\"]","portal","data",{"_19":20,"_101":102,"_103":104,"_105":106,"_107":108,"_109":110,"_18":111},"dataUpdateCount",1,"dataUpdatedAt","error","errorUpdateCount",0,"errorUpdatedAt","fetchFailureCount","fetchFailureReason","fetchMeta","isInvalidated","success","fetchStatus","idle","entityType","Paper","taxonomies",[141,142,143],"events",[],"articles",[],"technologies",[],[112,113,114],{"_15":135,"_29":136,"_31":-5,"_32":-5,"_33":-5,"_34":-5,"_35":36,"_37":137,"_39":-5,"_40":41,"_42":138,"_44":139,"_120":140,"_51":-5,"_122":-5,"_123":-5,"_124":-5,"_59":-5,"_125":-5,"_126":-5,"_127":-5,"_128":-5,"_129":-5,"_66":136,"_67":-5},{"_15":130,"_29":131,"_31":-5,"_32":-5,"_33":-5,"_34":-5,"_35":36,"_37":132,"_39":-5,"_40":41,"_42":133,"_44":134,"_120":-5,"_51":-5,"_122":-5,"_123":-5,"_124":-5,"_59":-5,"_125":-5,"_126":-5,"_127":-5,"_128":-5,"_129":-5,"_66":131,"_67":-5},{"_15":115,"_29":116,"_31":-5,"_32":-5,"_33":-5,"_34":-5,"_35":36,"_37":117,"_39":-5,"_40":41,"_42":118,"_44":119,"_120":121,"_51":-5,"_122":-5,"_123":-5,"_124":-5,"_59":-5,"_125":-5,"_126":-5,"_127":-5,"_128":-5,"_129":-5,"_66":116,"_67":-5},"person_A5068413510","John Zimmerman","{\"openalex\":\"A5068413510\",\"orcid\":\"0000-0001-5299-8157\"}","2026-05-14T04:20:58.222567129","2026-05-23T06:10:21.21014207","orcid","0000-0001-5299-8157","affiliation","researchArea","paperCount","homepage","linkedin","twitter","github","hindex","person_A5043211253","Erik Stolterman","{\"openalex\":\"A5043211253\"}","2026-05-15T15:06:29.177115822","2026-05-22T16:59:02.193328372","person_A5078288310","Jodi Forlizzi","{\"openalex\":\"A5078288310\",\"orcid\":\"0000-0002-7161-075X\"}","2026-05-14T04:20:58.300979277","2026-05-23T06:10:21.221437411","0000-0002-7161-075X",{"_15":166,"_29":70,"_31":-5,"_32":-5,"_33":-5,"_34":-5,"_35":36,"_37":167,"_39":-5,"_40":41,"_42":168,"_44":169,"_148":149,"_150":-5,"_151":26,"_152":153,"_154":170,"_156":92,"_157":158,"_159":92,"_160":-5,"_66":70,"_67":-5},{"_15":161,"_29":68,"_31":-5,"_32":-5,"_33":-5,"_34":-5,"_35":36,"_37":162,"_39":-5,"_40":41,"_42":163,"_44":164,"_148":149,"_150":-5,"_151":26,"_152":153,"_154":165,"_156":92,"_157":158,"_159":92,"_160":-5,"_66":68,"_67":-5},{"_15":144,"_29":69,"_31":-5,"_32":-5,"_33":-5,"_34":-5,"_35":36,"_37":145,"_39":-5,"_40":41,"_42":146,"_44":147,"_148":149,"_150":-5,"_151":26,"_152":153,"_154":155,"_156":92,"_157":158,"_159":92,"_160":-5,"_66":69,"_67":-5},"tax_rd_T14074","{\"openalex_topic\":\"T14074\"}","2026-05-14T01:25:37.235335584","2026-05-23T12:17:34.279187844","taxonomyType","RESEARCH_DOMAIN","code","level","parentId","tax_rd_1709","path","Physical Sciences/Computer Science/Human-Computer Interaction/Persona Design and Applications","sortOrder","isLeaf",true,"entityCount","children","tax_rd_T10803","{\"openalex_topic\":\"T10803\"}","2026-05-14T01:03:47.361075572","2026-05-23T12:04:09.319995775","Physical Sciences/Computer Science/Human-Computer Interaction/Innovative Human-Technology Interaction","tax_rd_T10470","{\"openalex_topic\":\"T10470\"}","2026-05-14T00:51:24.308048178","2026-05-23T12:40:56.318020959","Physical Sciences/Computer Science/Human-Computer Interaction/Usability and User Interface Design",{"_71":172,"_73":173},[],[174],{"_76":175,"_78":176,"_80":177,"_82":178},1784562376692,{"_85":180,"_87":88,"_89":175,"_90":-5,"_91":92,"_93":92,"_94":92,"_95":-5,"_96":-5,"_97":65,"_35":98,"_99":100},[84,179],"[\"portal\",\"industries\"]","industries",[181,182,183,184,185,186,187,188,189,190,191,192],{"_15":244,"_29":245,"_31":-5,"_32":246,"_33":247,"_34":-5,"_35":36,"_37":-5,"_39":-5,"_40":196,"_42":-5,"_44":-5,"_148":197,"_150":-5,"_151":88,"_152":198,"_154":248,"_156":92,"_157":65,"_159":92,"_160":-5,"_66":245,"_67":247},{"_15":240,"_29":241,"_31":-5,"_32":-5,"_33":242,"_34":-5,"_35":36,"_37":-5,"_39":-5,"_40":196,"_42":-5,"_44":-5,"_148":197,"_150":-5,"_151":88,"_152":198,"_154":243,"_156":92,"_157":65,"_159":92,"_160":-5,"_66":241,"_67":242},{"_15":234,"_29":235,"_31":-5,"_32":236,"_33":237,"_34":-5,"_35":36,"_37":-5,"_39":-5,"_40":196,"_42":-5,"_44":-5,"_148":197,"_150":-5,"_151":88,"_152":198,"_154":238,"_156":92,"_157":65,"_159":92,"_160":-5,"_66":235,"_67":237},{"_15":230,"_29":231,"_31":-5,"_32":-5,"_33":232,"_34":-5,"_35":36,"_37":-5,"_39":-5,"_40":196,"_42":-5,"_44":-5,"_148":197,"_150":-5,"_151":88,"_152":198,"_154":233,"_156":92,"_157":65,"_159":92,"_160":-5,"_66":231,"_67":232},{"_15":226,"_29":227,"_31":-5,"_32":-5,"_33":228,"_34":-5,"_35":36,"_37":-5,"_39":-5,"_40":196,"_42":-5,"_44":-5,"_148":197,"_150":-5,"_151":88,"_152":198,"_154":229,"_156":92,"_157":65,"_159":92,"_160":-5,"_66":227,"_67":228},{"_15":220,"_29":221,"_31":-5,"_32":222,"_33":223,"_34":-5,"_35":36,"_37":-5,"_39":-5,"_40":196,"_42":-5,"_44":-5,"_148":197,"_150":-5,"_151":88,"_152":198,"_154":224,"_156":92,"_157":65,"_159":92,"_160":-5,"_66":221,"_67":223},{"_15":216,"_29":217,"_31":-5,"_32":-5,"_33":218,"_34":-5,"_35":36,"_37":-5,"_39":-5,"_40":196,"_42":-5,"_44":-5,"_148":197,"_150":-5,"_151":88,"_152":198,"_154":219,"_156":92,"_157":158,"_159":92,"_160":-5,"_66":217,"_67":218},{"_15":212,"_29":213,"_31":-5,"_32":-5,"_33":214,"_34":-5,"_35":36,"_37":-5,"_39":-5,"_40":196,"_42":-5,"_44":-5,"_148":197,"_150":-5,"_151":88,"_152":198,"_154":215,"_156":92,"_157":65,"_159":92,"_160":-5,"_66":213,"_67":214},{"_15":208,"_29":209,"_31":-5,"_32":-5,"_33":210,"_34":-5,"_35":36,"_37":-5,"_39":-5,"_40":196,"_42":-5,"_44":-5,"_148":197,"_150":-5,"_151":88,"_152":198,"_154":211,"_156":92,"_157":65,"_159":92,"_160":-5,"_66":209,"_67":210},{"_15":204,"_29":205,"_31":-5,"_32":-5,"_33":206,"_34":-5,"_35":36,"_37":-5,"_39":-5,"_40":196,"_42":-5,"_44":-5,"_148":197,"_150":-5,"_151":88,"_152":198,"_154":207,"_156":92,"_157":65,"_159":92,"_160":-5,"_66":205,"_67":206},{"_15":200,"_29":201,"_31":-5,"_32":-5,"_33":202,"_34":-5,"_35":36,"_37":-5,"_39":-5,"_40":196,"_42":-5,"_44":-5,"_148":197,"_150":-5,"_151":88,"_152":198,"_154":203,"_156":92,"_157":65,"_159":92,"_160":-5,"_66":201,"_67":202},{"_15":193,"_29":194,"_31":-5,"_32":-5,"_33":195,"_34":-5,"_35":36,"_37":-5,"_39":-5,"_40":196,"_42":-5,"_44":-5,"_148":197,"_150":-5,"_151":88,"_152":198,"_154":199,"_156":92,"_157":65,"_159":92,"_160":-5,"_66":194,"_67":195},"tax_ind_smartphone","智能手机","Smartphone","manual","INDUSTRY","tax_ind_root","科技行业/智能手机","tax_ind_robot","机器人","Robotics","科技行业/机器人","tax_ind_wearable","智能穿戴","Smart Wearables","科技行业/智能穿戴","tax_ind_energy","新能源与智能制造","New Energy & Smart Manufacturing","科技行业/新能源与智能制造","tax_ind_biotech","生物科技","Biotech","科技行业/生物科技","tax_ind_quantum","量子计算","Quantum Computing","科技行业/量子计算","tax_ind_blockchain","区块链",[225],"Blockchain","科技行业/区块链","Web3","tax_ind_enterprise","企业软件","Enterprise Software","科技行业/企业软件","tax_ind_security","网络安全","Cybersecurity","科技行业/网络安全","tax_ind_semi","半导体",[239],"Semiconductor","科技行业/半导体","芯片","tax_ind_cloud","云计算","Cloud Computing","科技行业/云计算","tax_ind_ai","人工智能",[249,250],"Artificial Intelligence","科技行业/人工智能","AI","AI 技术","env",{"_253":24},"SITE_BASE_URL"]

An analysis and critique of<i>Research through Design</i> 论文

An analysis and critique of<i>Research through Design</i> · 作者